Rx for Writers

Writer's Support Room - Open Forum Transcripts

Event start time:

Tue Sep 20 06:39:45 2005

Event end time:

Tue Sep 20 15:27:47 2005



Legend:
Questions from the Audience are presented in red.
Answers by the Speaker are in black.
The Moderator's comments are in blue.

mel boring

A WARM WELCOME to the OPEN FORUM, beginning in about two minutes!

mel boring

We will have TONS of GOOD NEWS at the Open Forum today, and I am SO GLAD you're here!

mel boring

WELCOME to the Tuesday Open Forum for September 20!

mel boring

I won't issue my "standard paragraphs" today, but give help as needed as we go along....

mel boring

An ESPECIALLY WARM WELCOME if you're here for the first time!...

mel boring

Please remember NOT to just type your questions into the slot at the bottom of your screen...

mel boring

because they will mix in with the flow of answers....

mel boring

Instead, use the ask-a-question feature of the software you're using....

mel boring

For most of you, that will mean clicking on the little "thought cloud" in the middle of the screen....

mel boring

Then type your question into the box that opens...

mel boring

You MIGHT have to type a little piece at a time, but don't worry,...

mel boring

I will "piece them back together" gladly on this end!...

mel boring

Here are many GOOD NEWSes:

mel boring

Donna Marie West had TWO GOOD NEWSes in one week: my article, "On Matters of the Sphinx" just appeared in WHAT IF? so that's two good newses in a week!

mel boring

You may remember that Donna let us know about...

mel boring

the article she had published in HORSEPOWER last week....

mel boring

She has published MANY articles there AND in WHAT IF?...

mel boring

CONGRATULATIONS, Donna Marie West! Donna is an ICL grad who has done WELL in getting published.

mel boring

Here are two GOOD NEWSes of different kinds:...

mel boring

A GOLDEN OPPORTUNITY for YOU from Lucie Antoniazzi, otherwise known as peanut: As you already know, I’m senior editor at justformom.com for all of the articles that get published on the site.  I am not responsible for the recipes section of the site, as well, and I am preparing the selection of favorite recipes for our Fall 2005 page.  Can you put out a call for fall favorite recipes at the ICL forum?  If people are interested in contributing, they can send their recipes enclosed within an e-mail to: recipes@justformom.com.  If they have a photograph of the completed recipe, they can attach that to the e-mail in jpeg format.  The deadline for fall recipes is September 30, 2005.  If people want to check out the recipes section before they submit, they can visit:

 http://www.justformom.com/recipes/release-recipes.php

Thanks for your help, Mel!

mel boring

THANK YOU, Lucie, for this opportunity for us!...

mel boring

I know that MANY of you have tasty recipes, because I've tasted some of them!...

mel boring

So submit and be published in JustForMom, one of the BEST online magazines I know of!

 

Here's the BEST kind of GOOD NEWS:...

mel boring

Charlotte Mayo sent us this BEST kind of GOOD NEWS: Anyone wishing to help SCBWI (Society of Children's Writers & Illustrators) send COMFORT KITS to the displaced children of hurricane Katrina they can do the following. SCBWI will be placing--2 new books, a flashlight, a toothbrush, toothpaste set, a new toy or stuffed animal to each child. Buy new books (either hard or soft cover) new toy or stuffed animal toys and send them to the address given at the SCBWI’s Web Site at www.scbwi.org   DEADLINE IS SEPT 25 (all gifts must received by the SCBWI by then)

mel boring

THANK YOU, Charlotte, for letting us know of this opportunity to give!...

mel boring

The SCBWI has responded this way to MANY crises, and it is a GREAT opportunity for children's writers!

 

Here is a GIFT from Kristi Holl:...

mel boring

THANKS to Kristi Holl for sending us info about downloading the free manuscript tracker from Children's Book Insider. It is a freebie chart to track manuscripts, and you can get it by going to their Web Site at:

mel boring

 

 

 

 

 

 

mel boring

 

 

 

 

Someone asked very recently about the

 

manuscript itinerary," which is...

mel boring

this very kind of RECORD of submitted manuscripts....

mel boring

This one from Children's Book Insider is a GREAT one!...

 

Go to: http://write4kids.com/charts.html   You will need the Adobe Reader to read and display the tracker.  Get it at:

http://www.adobe.com/products/acrobat/readstep2.html

 

mel boring

While you're there at http://write4kids.com, you may want to look over what's in the CHILDREN'S BOOK INSIDER, a MARVELOUS e-zine for children's writers!

mel boring

One more item, to add to our answer to the question of novel-writing software from LAST week:...

mel boring

Last week, RM asked about novel-writing software, and I said that I've never used it, but would ask you chatsters if you knew of any. AGAIN, I learned that all of us are smarter than any of us, because caq mentioned Dramatica. Its Web Site is:

http://www.dramatica.com/

They have, not only a software program for writing novels, but books, CDs, audio tapes and a discussion group by users of Dramatica.  They even have MP3s you can download from the Internet that tell about their program.  If anyone else knows of any OTHER novel-writing software, please let me know and I will pass it on to chatsters.  And THANKS for asking, RM!

rosez

Mel, are you going to update us on your good news this week?

mel boring

And thank YOU for asking, rosez!...

mel boring

My good news is about the book I wrote with Leslie Dendy,...

mel boring

GUINEA PIG SCIENTISTS: BOLD SELF-EXPERIMENTERS IN SCIENCE AND MEDICINE:...

mel boring

Recently the book received a STARRED review from BOOKLIST, the book review mag of the American Library Association,...

mel boring

which also awards the Newbery Medal and the Caldecott Medal....

mel boring

A STARRED review is very rare, so Leslie and I are grateful!...

mel boring

ALSO, the book has been nominated for the Young Adult Book of the Year (along with about 100 others)....

mel boring

The YA Book Award is ALSO given by the American Library Association....

mel boring

The book came out this past June, and Leslie and I feel VERY fortunate--and THANK YOU for asking, rosez!

mel boring

/ Mel, I'm thrilled to announce the September release of my preschool picture book, HOW WILL I EVER SLEEP IN THIS BED? I just got my author copies and I *think* it should be in bookstores any day now!

mel boring

CONGRATULATIONS to YOU, dell!...

mel boring

That is marvelous news, a picture book release. HOW WILL I EVER SLEEP IN THIS BED sounds like...

brenbo              

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

mel boring

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

ljp

I sent my first manuscript out - only to get my first

rejection back in less than a week. Then two more followed

in less than three weeks time. I studied the market, too.

When publishers respond with a reject that fast, what does

doest that mean? Since it was my first submission, I was

realistic and expected to get rejects, but not THAT fast!

I have to admit I was taken back by that.  Can you help me

make sense of it, especially the one that I received back in

less than a week because that makes me think they didn't

even take the time to read it.

 

I'm SORRY, brenbo, because I KNOW how rejections hurt--especially THREE rejections!...

Quick rejections simply mean that they were not too busy to respond right away....

But it does NOT mean they didn't read it....

What happens at MOST magazines and publishers is that they have "readers"...

who make the first reading of a submitted manuscript….

Those readers are fully trained to know right away if the submission is just not appropriate for THAT publication, brenbo….  And that MIGHT be the reason for the quick returns.  If a magazine specializes at all, there are certain kinds of stories and articles.... that, though they may be WELL written, it's just not their kind of piece....

 

submission is just not appropriate for THAT publication, brenbo....

mel boring

And that MIGHT be the reason for the returns....I have gotten around 600 rejections of my writing now…SOME of them came VERY quickly, and I too suspected they hadn’t read the pieces….But I know NOW that they DO read everything, unless they are a publisher who for…some reason doesn’t receive submisssions; and they will TELL you that plainly….I hope you’ll go ON submitting, brenbo….and think of each rejection as a STEPPING STONE toward your first ACCEPTANCE….Children’s publishing is a TOUGH, COMPETITIVE business, so you must expect rejection, friend….I received 144 rejections from 1969 to 1971 before I received my first acceptance.  YOUR first acceptance is OUT there, brenbo—keep trying for it, and let us know when it happens, PLEASE!

 

 

 

 

ljp

This person wants to know about the recipes wanted at JustForMom:...

 

 

do they want just recipes or an article to go with?

mel boring

If peanut is here, she will let us know, and I will pass the info on, ljp.

inky

Here is an additional note about the SCBWI's Katrina relief kit:...

paige

 

 

 

 

 

The SCBWI welcome checks (the cost for a kit) for the Katrina kids, for those who do not want to make up a kit themselves.

mel boring

THANK YOU, paige, what a NEEDED CLARIFIER you sent us!

mel boring

 

cosmos

Here are some helpful responses for brenbo:...

 

Bren remember that it takes 100 rejections then hopefully publication. At least that's what most writers have told me. I'm still working on those rejections myself.

 

I just got a personal rejection from the New Yorker...my BEST one ever!

mel boring

THANK YOU for that encouragement, inky and cosmos!!!...

dell

And remember that when you're collecting those 100 rejections (144 in my case!)...

inky

Here or there might be a jotted handwritten note to ask you to submit to them again....

spotslover2

And THAT is very encouraging, brenbo. I don't think I could have continued in the face of 144 rejections in 1969 to 1971 if I hadn't gotten a few of those VERY SHORT notes on the rejection slips!

rosehips

And here are some VERY ENCOURAGING NOTES for me, said Mel with a blush:...

gladys1

/ congratulations, Mel!!

mewf

Impressive :-)

mel boring

Well done, Mel. That's impressive!

mel boring

Wow Mel! We're proud of YOU!

caq

way to go Mel

caq

CONGRATULATIONS TO MEL AND LESLIE! WAY TO GO!

caq

THANK YOU so MUCH, dell and inky and spotslover2 and rosehips and gladys1 and mewf!!!...

caq

You can have NO idea how MUCH your words mean to me, and I am misty in the eyes to read them!

caq

Mel, someone made this statement on chat and I think...

caq

it is important to clear up: “I don’t worry about my ...

caq

spelling and grammar. If the publisher likes it he/she ...

caq

will take care of it.” Can you give your opinion on this...

mel boring

just to let others know? I disagree whole-heartedly. ...

mel boring

Good grammar and spelling is a sign of professionalism ...

mel boring

isn’t it? They won’t even look at your MS if your cover...

mel boring

letter is full of errors in most cases, will they?

mel boring

You're absolutely right, caq, that spelling and punctuation errors will turn editors off to your writing....

lisalisa

Their "rule of thumb" is that after THREE spelling errors, they will stop reading a piece.....

mel boring

It is true that they also search every piece they publish for errors,...

inky

BUT it will mean less work for THEM and a better impression of YOU if you fix EVERY spelling and punctuation error....

mel boring

THANKS for bringing that up, caq!

mel boring

Mel, was the review of your book in the 9/1/05 Booklist?

mel boring

Yes, I think so, lisalisa. Actually, a friend told me about it, and I don't subscribe to BOOKLIST online or in hard copy, but it was about September 1 when my friend mentioned it.

mel boring

Mel--LongRidge Writers Group is also supposed to having a novel class. Mary Rosenblum was working on writing the program.

mel boring

Yes, inky, The Long Ridge Writers Group IS the adult writing course group of ICL....

mel boring

I don't know yet if Mary's program is out, and I think they would've told me if it is....

cosmos

Here's how to keep checking:...

mel boring

Go to www.institutechildrenslit.com

mel boring

and click on WRITING FOR ADULTS on the left side of that home site...

mel boring

That will take you to the Long Ridge site, and I'm sure Mary Rosenblum will announce her special novel course when it's ready, inky. THANKS for asking@

mel boring

Mel, is there a market for an article about genetically engineered foods? When I first submitted my article, I was told by Highlights that it was too contraversial. I phoned a scientist from Monsanto on the east coast as a basis of much of my article.

mel boring

Yes, there WOULD be a market for such an article, cosmos,...

gladys1

but HIGHLIGHTS would not want to handle controversial subjects....

caq

Look in your market guide for children's magazines that...

mel boring

are about FOOD and NUTRITION, and you're bound to find one that will handle that controversial subject.

mel boring

Here's more help about recipes for the JustForMom Web Site:...

bish

hi Mel I think a recipe alone is okay but it would be advisable to check out the website.

mel boring

Mel can they get on the just for moms web site and find out or ask them from there?

mel boring

THANKS, gladys1 and caq!...

mel boring

I will make it a point to find out more specifics for next week's Open Forum, too.

mel boring

I'm sorry I came in late. What's in the kit?

inky

Let's see if I can remember; The SCBWI is sending out to children who are victims of the Katrina Hurricane....

spotslover2

a kit with toothpaste, soap, a toy, and a children's book....

samscratch

I'll try to check back on the e-mail I received from inky--or maybe YOU can let us know, inky, if that's an accurate list! We'll have a game of MEMORY here!

mel boring

Here is HELPFUL info about submitting to the JustForMom site:...

mel boring

mel just went to the justformom website--they are requesting just recipe and if you want to send a photo you may as an attachment. to receipe@justformom.com

mel boring

I just checked the Just for Mom site and looked at the recipes they have already. All that's included is the recipe, but include preparation and cooking time and any substitutions.

mewf

How large of picture do they want with the reipes?

mel boring

THANKS, inky and spotslover2!...

mel boring

and samscratch, they would want a digital photo that wouldn't need to be very big...

mel boring

or a regular paper photo of, say, 4 inches by 6 inches. I'll ask Lucie about that for next time, too.

mel boring

Mel, if a magazine say they take 'talk-abouts' or 'instructional articles' does that cover just about anything, say from recipes to crafts?

mel boring

Yes, it could mean recipes to crafts, mewf....

mel boring

But it also might mean a regular article, say about PANDAS, if it was a nature magazine,...

mel boring

or a how-to article about how to call up your boyfriend or girlfriend and ask for a date,...

mel boring

depending on the magazine, and the age range they cover.

mel boring

EP asked us: I am working on a story that involves a criminal trial, and I need to do some research. Do you know of a good book or two I could for some ideas?

mel boring

I woiuld STRONGLY recommend TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRD, EP....

mel boring

It is at least HALF trial, that book...

mel boring

Also, most ANY book by John Grisham, a former lawyer, will contain MUCH courtroom work....

 

My FAVORITE of Grisham's is A TIME TO DIE ( I THINK is the exact title)...

mel boring

That book is about a black man accused of killing a white child, and was Grisham's first....

mel boring

It was rejected until he had sold OTHER novels, but I think it is his BEST!

mel boring

palady needs to know: When a publisher/agent asks for three (3) chapters, does the

10 pages etc.

 

mel boring

No, the prologue is separate, palady. And since a prologue must be SHORT,...

mel boring

an editor would find no problems in receiving B OTH the prologue and the THREE chapters.

mel boring

palady also needs to find out: Should the chapters of a novel be approximately the same

mel boring

 

your paragraphs are too descriptive

No, they can be very varied, palady, EXCEPT in "first books" for ages 4 to 6....

mel boring

In THAT case, they should be consistent, and shorter...

mel boring

But for novels for, say, age 8-12's, they can be both long and short, of a good variety.

mel boring

iluv2write e-mailed to ask: How descriptive should a children's book be? Is there

mel boring

 

mel boring

A children's book should generally be about HALF dialogue, iluv2write....

mel boring

and that means the other half can be description, plus narration....

a submission format--name, etc?

The BEST TEST is to read your description and...

mel boring

strike out EVERY word that is not really necessary....

mel boring

Also, read it over and ask: Will children be bored by this much description?

mel boring

Kenbo wants to find out: If you are yet unpublished, do you include an entire article you have written in submission format or just some paragraphs from several different articles. And then would you put

mel boring

 

mel boring

If you have an article that is, say, three pages long, Kenbo,...

 

that would be fine. But if you are submitting MORE than ONE article sample, just use the first page of each....

 

Samples are to just give an editor the flavor of your writing, and need not be complete....

 

JB asks: What is the best way to check verb tense?

mel boring

JB also asks: What is the past tense of sneak?

mel boring

 

mel boring

 

mel boring

 

mel boring

The best place to check verb tense is in the dictionary entry for the word, JB....

mel boring

After the pronunciation, they willl have sometning like:...

mel boring

"think, thought, have thought" for the tenses of "think."...

cosmos

and the present tense is given first, then past tense, then the past perfect (the one with had or have in it)....

mel boring

and the correct past tense of "sneak" is...

gladys1

SNEAKED or SNUCK, BOTH are acceptable, JB.

mel boring

Here's a very HELPFUL word about rejection from cosmos:...

mel boring

Rejections show effort and that you're trying. I collect my rejections in a notebook. If you never give up and you keep working hard to submit, you will find success. I think the point is to NEVER GIVE UP!

mel boring

I say AWOMEN to that, cosmos! THANK YOU!!!

gladys1

Mel boy do I have a long way to go I have only 14 rejections to 2 on line publications

mel boring

You are ON YOUR WAY, gladys1!...

cosmos

AND you've been published even BEFORE 100 rejections!....

mel boring

Also, I've read your online publications, and they are top-rate, friend!!

mel boring

Mel that was the ones I kept track of so the rejections may be more

mel boring

Go get 'em, gladys1!

eggamy

Congratulations, Mel. We're looking forward to reading your book!

mel boring

THANK YOU, cosmos, that is VERY encouraging to me!...

mel boring

You may be able to sample a few pages at amazon.com

mel boring

I haven't tried that yet, and I will, though.

mel boring

is there information about the Highlights wish list?

cosmos

Hi, eggamy! Check the posting of LAST WEEK's Open Forum, where the e-mail address is from which you can get a copy via e-mail, friend.

mel boring

OOPS, I must go, since there were no storms today, and I never got knocked off!...

mel boring

THANK YOU for taking the time out of your day to join us!!!....

 

And I wish QUICK PUBLICATION to ALL of you children's writers!...

 

Thanks so much, Mel. You're the BEST!

 

Thank YOU, cosmos, but I think YOU ALL are the VERY BEST!

 

Bye for this week!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Return to Open Forum Transcripts

93 Long Ridge Road, West Redding, CT 06896
Phone: (203) 792-8600 (800) 243-9645
Fax: (203) 792-8406
E-Mail:
WebEditor@institutechildrenslit.com

Home | Writing Course | Short Story  | Full Story | Aptitude Test 
 
Send Me Info | EnrollOur Instructors | Our Credentials | Sample Lesson
College Credits |
Tax Deductibility | From Overseas | Writer's Bookstore 
Newsletter | Writing Contests | Write for Adults | Free Writer's News
 
Rx for Writers | Chat Room | Open Forum | Writing Tips  | Scheduled Events | Transcripts
Writer's Retreat | Writer's Support  | Student  Center |  Privacy Policy | Web Editor | Comments

Copyright © The Institute, Inc., 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006
No part of the electronic transmission to which this notice is appended may be reproduced or redistributed in any form or manner without the express written permission of The Institute, Inc.