Rx for Writers

Writer's Support Room - Open Forum Transcripts

Event start time: Tue Dec 06 13:58:03 2005
Event end time: Tue Dec 06 15:07:11 2005


Legend:
Questions from the Audience are presented in red.
Answers by the Speaker are in black.
The Moderator's comments are in blue.

mel boring Join us this afternoon in the AUDITORIUM-Scheduled Events Room for an "Open Forum" with Web Editor Mel Boring. Mel has published some 25 magazine articles and stories, as well as eight books for the young readers market. He taught writing for 18 years, while being home husband and parent to two of his four children, and doing his own writing. He welcomes your questions on time management, getting started, writer's block, marketing, writing rights, writing earnings, or anything else you'd like to discuss. Bring your QUESTIONS to this open forum-in five minutes.
mel boring The Tuesday afternoon "Open Forum" will begin promptly at 4 Atlantic/CANADA, 3 p.m. Eastern, 2 p.m. Central, 1 p.m. Mountain, and noon Pacific. While you wait for the "Open Forum" to start, feel free to use your ASK A QUESTION button RIGHT BETWEEN THE YELLOW "MAP" AND THE RED QUESTION MARK IN ICHAT to post some questions for the discussion group-two minutes from now.
mel boring Good afternoon! Welcome to this Tuesday afternoon's "Open Forum" session. I'm your moderator, Mel Boring, and the Web Editor for this site. We're back for an informal time of answering any questions you might like to ask, on any subject. So feel free to ask what's on your mind--and I'll tell you what's on mine! First, please read these announcements, then we'll get started….
mel boring IMPORTANT INSTRUCTIONS: Send questions you'd like answered or discussed by using your "Ask a Question" icon/button. (It looks like a thought bubble icon, RIGHT NEXT TO THE RED QUESTION MARK.) The moderator (me, Mel Boring) will post the questions one at a time in the chat room and do my best to answer them. Also note: If you want to make it possible to ask the longest question you can, first type "/ask" (without the quotation marks), then leave one space after the end of "ask", then type as many characters of your question as you can. If your question is not complete, send the second part next, then if necessary the third, etc…
mel boring WARNING: If you don't post anything at all, SOME of you will be bounced off the system in 15 minutes. TO PREVENT THIS, type something (either a question to the moderator or even a private message) every 15 minutes to stay active and remain online.
mel boring Here, first, is the Tasty Word of the Forum:...
mel boring soffit\SAW-fit\ noun...
mel boring I'll tell you that it's a noun because it's a rather unusual word--soft-sounding! (-:}
mel boring Send me your definitions!
mel boring And NOW, CONGRATULATIONS to George Kulz!!!:
george kulz Mel, I wanted to let everyone know that I'm now an official graduate of ICL! :-)
mel boring . o O ( CHEERSCHEERSCHEERSCHEERSCHEERSCHEERSCHEERS!!! )
mel boring WayToGo, George!!!
mel boring AND, gladys1 took the day off just to be here with us today--A WARM WELCOME, gladys1!!!
mel boring arnalda/Diana sent us her GOOD NEWS: Today in the mail, I received my contributor copies from My Friend magazine. The December '05 issue has my story/article titled “Saint Thomas and the Log: Two Miracles.”
mel boring HIGH CONGRATULATIONS, arnalda/Diana!!!...
mel boring Your contributor copies are worth their weight in gold--so hold onto as many as you can!...
mel boring Send COPIES of the story/article to editors, instead of the ORIGINAL copies, my friend....
mel boring I want to send our DEEP SYMPATHY to arnalda/Diana,...
mel boring because her father so recently died, and suddenly. Our hearts go out to you, our friend!!!
dell Mel, I've got some good news this week. I sold an action rhyme to Highlights. It's called "The Teddy Bear Bounce" and is my first poetry sale to them!
mel boring CONGRATULATIONS, dell, you VERY SUCCESSFUL picture book publisher!!!...
mel boring We are TICKLED for you that you sold to HIGHLIGHTS, and I'll be looking for that poem, "The Teddy Bear Bounce" in my copies!!!
mel boring This GOOD NEWS comes from Karen McCauley: My story "The Healing Garden" is in the December issue of CHARACTERS Magazine.
mel boring GOOD NEWS from Gladys Swedak, too!!!...
mel boring Her story, "Losing Femininity" has been published on LongStoryShort, and is a TRULY TOUCHING story from her own life....
mel boring CONGRATULATIONS, Gladys!!!...
mel boring You can read the story, as I did, at:...
mel boring http://www.alongstoryshort.homestead.com/LOSINGFEMININITY.html
mel boring This GOOD NEWS comes from Karen McCauley: My story "The Healing Garden" is in the December issue of CHARACTERS Magazine.
mel boring OUR HIGH TENS to you, Karey McCauley!!!!!!!!!!...
mel boring "The Healing Garden" is a MARVELOUS title, and I'll bet your story MATCHES that title, friend!!! CONGRATS!!!
aurora1 Thanks everyone, Karen
aurora1 congrats to you, Gladys!!!
gladys1 Mel thanks
mel boring You are WARMLY WELCOME, Karen and Gladys--we are ALL VERY PROUD of YOU!!!
mel boring Now to "soffit," that soft-sounding word:...
caq Soffit - the board about your cupboards and the ceiling. Some people just have space, others put in a soffit. I have to strip mine of wallpaper in the new house!!! I have seen enough soffit for a while.
mel boring This person who is JUST remodeling her new home knows that word!...
mel boring You're right, caq! A soffit is the boards at the top of your cupboards,...
mel boring and also the boards under your eaves outside,...
mel boring and also the underside of stairways--a real "constructive" word, don't you think? (-:}
gladys1 Mel I have never used a "a" in the url just www.LongStoryShort.us
mel boring THANKS for letting us know, Gladys!
tolkienlvr Mel, if you've worked with an "assistant editor" at a mag recently and have a relationship with them, and are submitting a new query, but the mag wants all query's sent to the big "editor" : ), is there an appropriate way to let the "assistant editor" know you have submitted again? Or no?
mel boring Yes, tolkienlvr....
mel boring What I'd suggest is that you DO submit to the "big editor" (-:}...
mel boring but ALSO drop the assistant editor a note to let THAT person know you've made a submission, too, though not to send the assistant a copy of the manuscript....
mel boring Just a "thought you'd like to know" kind of e-mail, tolkienlvr.
obrienj Can you submit a draft to more than one publisher
mel boring Hi, obrienj!...
mel boring GOOD question! And you CAN do that, for sure, IF their listings state that they will consider "simultaneous submissions."...
mel boring It's always polite, too, to let them know that it IS being submitted to (an)other(s), obrienj....
mel boring But if a listing says "no simultaneous submissions," you'll know they want an EXCLUSIVE look at it.
mel boring t green asks: I just received a contract for a Devotions Book for Moms. It outlines all the rights and other stuff, but I'm confused. It looks like they want all rights exclusively. What do I do now?
www.justformom.com, what I see there for rights they take is:
in the form of a byline. By submission of material, you grant JFM one-time electronic and archival rights for one year." If that ISN'T the site you meant by "Moms," please reply, OK
tolkienlvr thanks mel!
mel boring You are WARMLY WELCOME, tolkienlvr!
spotslover2 You might say caq has had a surfeit of soffit.
mel boring HA, LOL!...
caq Since the soffit is the underside of or covering of spaces, etc. I think it should also be used as a word to describe the underside or subplot in a story. The soffet of a story.
mel boring EXCELLENT, caq, very creative!
mel boring bassoonhny asks: Would you suggest finishing the ICL coursework before submitting a story for publication or making the attempt before graduation?
mel boring The BEST guide as to when to submit is to look to your instructor, bassoonhny....
mel boring And even ASK your instructor if they don't mention it....
mel boring As an instructor till 2000, I ALWAYS encouraged my students to send out a story for publication...
mel boring when THEY felt they were ready to submit....
mel boring It DOES NOT MATTER if it's before graduation, bassoonhny,...
mel boring you can STILL submit. But it's good to ask your instructor about it....
mel boring By the way, bassoonhny RIGHT AT THIS MOMENT is playing...
mel boring The Nutcracker Suite on her bassoon in the schools in her community!!!...
mel boring CHEERS FOR YOU, bassoonhny!!!
mel boring And MERRY CHRISTMAS to you!
mel boring BR has this musical question: Over the last 28 years of composing music and writing lyrics in Southern Gospel Music, I have published about 5 or 6 specific children's songs, and have a few more that have a theme adaptable for young people. My idea is to write a story, and put the songs into the story, but not necessarily as a musical. Does that make any sense? Is there a market for a children's book that would tell a story, and have songs in the story to enhance it?
mel boring I would suggest you GO FOR IT, BR!!!...
mel boring Here is why:...
mel boring If someone had asked years ago, "What if I wrote a story about a boy who snuck out on Christmas Eve...
mel boring and went on a train to the North Pole and met Santa Claus...
mel boring and got a present from Santa, a bell that no adults could hear....
mel boring I hope as an editor I would NOT have said NO to that POLAR EXPRESS by Von Alsberg, that became such a HUGE Christmas hit!...
mel boring So what I'm saying, BR, is that YOU may have an idea now in your "song-stories" that could become QUITE successful...
mel boring So GO FOR IT, my friend!
teriabc an agent that i queried asked for temporary exclucivity
teriabc while the material is in there office. Do you know the
teriabc amount of time an answer usually takes from an agent...
teriabc this puts a hold on the submission process
mel boring THANKS for sharing your experience, teriabc!...
mel boring AGENTS can and DO usually claim exclusivity...
mel boring because they will be considering taking you on as a client....
mel boring So they NEED to have things usually on hold to consider agenting a writer....
mel boring Usually agents are REALLY QUICK!...
mel boring I would say a couple of weeks, to at most a month, would be the amount of time it takes to hear from an agent...
mel boring If you DON'T by then, I would feel free to contact them again, teriabc.
bechu If you submit a song with a storey do you provide the music?
mel boring Probably that would be best, bechu....
mel boring Because the words of the SONG would have to be tailored to the music, and an editor would want to see how the WORDS work with the MUSIC, friend.
casey After Gladys let us know that her story was up on LongStoryShort, I had to check because my "Christmas Surprise" is there too.
mel boring CONGRATULATIONS, casey!!!...
mel boring THANK YOU for letting us know, and...
mel boring the FIRST thing I'm going to do after the forum is go READ your "Christmas Surprise"!....
mel boring Truly a Merry Christmas SURPRISE for us friends of yours, casey!!!
mel boring BIG THANKS to John Prophet for letting us know about this Web Site for FREE poetry contests:

mel boring MANY of you have asked about bona fide poetry contests...
mel boring and the fact that those John told us about are FREE probably means they're bona fide, since you won't be asked to buy the book your poem is in!
mel boring THANKS to Michelle Dyett-Welcome for letting us know about this offer from Echelon Press, who will accept submissions for ELECTRONIC publication. You can find out what they offer to publish, plus their guidelines at:

mel boring I don't know much about Echelon Press,...
mel boring but they look very GOOD, and I thought you'
mel boring would want to know about them.
mel boring Michelle Dyett-Welcome e-mailed to ask: Where would I find a good example of a writing resume? I have been unsuccessful in locating one. My regular resume is not proper to submit for a freelance writing job.
writing resume: There is a GOOD sample at Harold Underdown's Purple Crayon site, his OWN:

mel boring I already prepared that answer, because I wanted to make sure to get that URL right...
mel boring If you have never visited the Purple Crayon Web Site, there are GOBS OF GOODIES for children's writers there from our friend, Harold Underdown. I HIGHLY RECOMMEND that site!
mel boring bassoonhny also asked: When citing references for a magazine article, do editors prefer “hard copy" references such as books, magazines, etc., or will Web sites suffice?
mel boring Oh, bassoonhny, I can almost HEAR that Nutcracker Suite you're playing even as I answer, friend!!!...
mel boring Editors PREFER
mel boring books and magazine articles, for SURE, you got that right!...
mel boring And Web site references are good, unless ALL your references are just Web sites....
mel boring In a bibliography of, say, ten pieces, if two or three are Web sites, that would be acceptable....
mel boring Because many Web sites are unreliable and have no names or dates on them,...
mel boring editors look askance if ALL of your references are only Web sites, bassoonhny.
mel boring CC wants to know: With so many celebrities getting into the field of writing children's books, what chance does an unknown have to be published? Has this trend hurt our chances?
mel boring GOOD question, CC!...
mel boring You have as good a change competing with the celebrities as you do...
mel boring in competing with children's writers like Maurice Sendak and Jane Yolen and Sid Fleischman and Jane Kurtz, CC....
mel boring That is, the celebrities may sell MORE BOOKS just because of their names,...
mel boring but if their first book gets "thumbs-down" reviews, they aren't going to sell as many of the NEXT one....
mel boring Of ALL the celebrities, I hear the BEST things about two of them....
mel boring One of them is Paul McCartney and...
mel boring the other is Henry Winkler....
mel boring What I hear--AND have read in Winkler's....
mel boring is that they seem to REALLY CONNECT with kids....
mel boring But there are some celebs who may not be around long, like a certain rock singer who has only one name for herself. (-:}...
mel boring and I don't think celebs make any MORE competition for us than the really great and established children's writers.
mel boring RN asks: With folklore and fairy tales, there are many different varieties of the same story (e.g. how many Cinderella and Snow Whites are out there?) Is permission required to be requested if I were to use an obscure foreign folklore or old fairytale story and rewrite it completely in a modern setting especially if the folklore or fairytale was read in a published book of fairy tales say 40/60/100 years ago?
mel boring No permission needs to be asked for a Cinderella or Snow White story, RN, as long as it's not a word-for-word copy of one already published and copyrighted....
mel boring So you could write Cinderella in your OWN words, and no copyright problem....
mel boring If you REWRITE any folk tale or fairy tale in your OWN words, it doesn't matter when it was published....
mel boring In fact, there are take-offs on fairy tales, such as THE THREE PIGS that do NOthing to violate copyright because they are NEW stories, RN.
aurora1 congrats to you, Casey!!That was a surprise I'll bet
mel boring Hey, a Christmas Surprise for casey!....
mel boring That in itself sounds like a GOOD story title, aurora1!!!
mel boring But I think casey told us last summer that the story was scheduled....
mel boring CONGRATS again, casey, from us ALL!!!
dyett what should you do if an agent takes for ever to get back
dyett to you regarding your book proposal. over the time they stat
dyett state.
mel boring dyett, you should contact them after, at MOST, three months...
mel boring because the GOOD agents are QUICK, that is a SECRET of their success....
mel boring And a GOOD agent won't mind your contacting them after 3 months, dyett.
mel boring If they say one month, then I would contact them at, say, six weeks.
mel boring LK wrote to ask: I have a couple of stories that I sold to the same magazine over the past couple of years. I have submitted a couple of stories to them that were not purchased. My question is: When I submit new stories/articles to this same magazine, do I continue to remind them of the articles they have already bought from me?
mel boring No, you don't HAVE to remind them of our previous stories, LK,...
mel boring but it is a GOOD IDEA to refresh their memories that way, I think....
mel boring MOST editors have really prodigious memories, SUPERMEMORY, and can remember...
mel boring But it woudn't hurt to remind them that you have been previously published by them, LK....
mel boring And if there should come a NEW editor, by all means remind them!
caq Speaking of websites. Just for an example. I wrote a beaver article that included 2 websites. I checked the other week and found one is no longer available so I found a replacement to fill that slot that had that info. Make sure they are still active sites evern after first submissions.
mel boring Yes, THAT is the reason editors are leery of Web sites, good comment, caq!!!....
mel boring Web sites can come and go, so make SURE they're working links when you list them in your bibliography....
mel boring and keep checking on them up to your time of publication, to make sure they're still working.
mel boring If a Web site has an end-tag of ".org" or ".edu," they probably will be around for a long time, by the way.
rosez Mel, here is a contest I thought some writers might be inter-
rosez ested in. There is no fee involved but you have to submit online
rosez www.lhmint.org/christmas/contest.htm
mel boring A GOOD Christmas Gift for us, rosez, and THANK YOU!!!...
mel boring That sounds like a WINNER of a contest!
mel boring caq is asking: Grit says they purchase "shared rights". What does that mean? What rights do they share?
mel boring I have to say I have never heard the term "shared rights," caq....
mel boring but my guess is that you would be free to submit the piece elsewhere,...
mel boring that GRIT would share the rights with others....
mel boring When GRIT publishes the piece, the FIRST Rights are gone, as you know....
mel boring But Reprint Rights and/or Second Rights could be the ones they are talking about "sharing."...
mel boring I haven't had a chance yet, but I will look into that more for next Tuesday, OK?
dyett mel did I miss the answer about the resume's?
mel boring It will be in the transcript afterward, dyett, at:...
mel boring http://www.institutechildrenslit.com/rx/ws09/index.shtml
mel boring And THANKS for asking!@
mel boring MORE about celebrity authors!:...
crabby j Hi Mel. Also, most celeb "authors" have professional...
crabby j writers/editors, etc. working up the book, no?
mel boring Yes, they do, and spotslover2 has more about one of those celebs who DOES!...
spotslover2 Yeah, but Winkler has Lin Oliver to help him. John Lithgow's are good also.
mel boring You are RIGHT ON ALL COUNTS, spotslover2!
susan ralston what contest was rosz referring to?
mel boring It was a contest for Christmas, susan ralston, and the URL for finding out about it is: www.lhmint.ort/christmas/contest.htm
mel boring THANKS for bring it up again!
mel boring caq is asking: Grit says they purchase "shared rights". What does that mean? What rights do they share?
mel boring WHOOPS, already answered that, for now!
mel boring caq also asked: If a magazine wants clips and/or written samples, could they sometimes have an interest in the sample? In other words, isn't that a good way to advertise yourself to them?
mel boring YES, that's a GOOD possiblity, caq, if it's a topic they cover in nonfiction,...
mel boring or if it is RELATED to the kind of thing they publish....
mel boring It could "score points with them" for you!
mel boring High Hopes asked: Do you need to give a title to a puzzle or maze when you submit it?
mel boring No, you don't have to, High Hopes, but I would suggest that you DO...
mel boring The reason is that a title will make the puzzle of maze seem "complete."...
mel boring What will likely happen is that the editor will end up titling it themselves,...
mel boring but YOUR title will "give them something to go on," maybe a theme.
mel boring High Hopes asked too: The ICL website writers guidelines state an article should be 850-1200 words. Do you accept shorter articles?
mel boring Yes, in fact we HAVE HAD articles that were closer to 800 words, and used them, High Hopes.
mel boring RS followed up with this question: Mel, last week you clearly explained how one might expect an "average" or "good" book to make initially and then by the month. I'd like to know, if a books is average, how many months would it be likely to sustain this level of sales?
mel boring Probably for a few years anyway, RS...
mel boring The rule of thumb USED to be that a book that good would last about five years on the shelves...
mel boring But things move more swiftly nowadays....
mel boring But if your book was an average or good success, it would be around at least 2 or 3 years...
mel boring Here's a statistic. The "critter books" in a series that I've been part of...
mel boring have lasted TEN YEARS now, rather unusual....
mel boring But it is because the ILLUSTRATIONS are SO STRIKING, I think, that they have "lived so long."...'
mel boring But generally, if a book gets off to good sales, it will last several years, though the sales MIGHT taper off some over that time.
gladys1 Mel what is the name of your critter books
mel boring Oh-oh, you'd think I had brought that on, but I wasn't meaning to, gladys1...
mel boring One is called CATERPILLARS, BUGS AND BUTTERFLIES...
mel boring and they are from NorthWord Press, which is a way to find them at, say, Amazon.com.
mel boring Here is a final word I just HAVE to pass on, from vettemom:...
vettemom The best gift we can give our loved ones this holiday is....
vettemom a written word from the heart.
vettemom try it this year, you will be glad you did
mel boring AMEN and AWOMEN, vettemom!!! THANKS for that, my friend!!!...
mel boring BYE for now!...
mel boring THIS Thursday evening, we have as Chat Guests:....
mel boring Linda Lowery and Rick Keep,...
mel boring a wife and husband WRITER and ILLUSTRATOR TEAM....
mel boring They are TERRIFIC! I had such FUN with them in practice Monday....
mel boring You will LIKE chatting with them, I guarantee. "See you" Thursday evening?...
mel boring A Blessed Christmas time to you in these days just ahead!!!

Return to Open Forum Transcripts

93 Long Ridge Road, West Redding, CT 06896
Phone: (203) 792-8600 (800) 243-9645
Fax: (203) 792-8406
E-Mail:
WebEditor@institutechildrenslit.com

Home | Writing Course | Short Story  | Full Story | Aptitude Test 
 
Send Me Info | EnrollOur Instructors | Our Credentials | Sample Lesson
College Credits |
Tax Deductibility | From Overseas | Writer's Bookstore 
Newsletter | Writing Contests | Write for Adults | Free Writer's News
 
Rx for Writers | Chat Room | Open Forum | Writing Tips  | Scheduled Events | Transcripts
Writer's Retreat | Writer's Support  | Student  Center |  Privacy Policy | Web Editor | Comments

Copyright © The Institute, Inc., 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006
No part of the electronic transmission to which this notice is appended may be reproduced or redistributed in any form or manner without the express written permission of The Institute, Inc.